9. The Efforts of the Scholars to Preserve the Sunnah:
For many reasons, some people invariably tried to lie about the Prophet
and make up hadith and say they heard it from the Prophet. These people
had various motivations, but their final destination was clearly mentioned
to us by the Prophet, that they should be ready to take their seat in the
hell fire.
One of the biggest sources of liars about the Prophet were the
deviant groups, who tried to re-enforce their deviant ideas by producing
fake hadith. Some scholars have reported that the first deviant group to
start producing fake hadith was the Shia, who had no evidence from the
Qur'an or Sunnah and so they tried to fake hadith. In any case, we will
try to mention some of the efforts of how the scholars tried to combat
these deviant groups and their fake hadith:
1. Requiring a full isnad (chain of narrators) for each hadith before
accepting it. As we all know every hadith is composed of two parts: sanad
and matn. The sanad means the chain of narrators, which starts with the
person who heard the hadith from the Prophet, then the person who heard
from him and so on. The matn is the actual wording that the Prophet said.
Before adding a hadith to their collection, the scholars required that
they hear the entire chain of narrators for it up to the person saying the
hadith.
2. After hearing the sanad, the scholars used historical evidence to
expose liars who had just invented the hadith. This is because the
scholars had books detailing narrators of hadith, which were of course
mostly scholars and their students. They knew during what years they
lived, and in what cities they lived and so on. Therefore, they can expose
inaccuracies in the sanad which prove that the person is lying.
3. The books about the narrators also included information about each
narrator such as: how religious he was, if he attended prayers, if his
beliefs were correct, if he belonged to any deviant groups, if he was ever
known to lie etc. Therefore, after checking the historical accuracy of the
sanad (to ensure that every narrator met with the previous one in the
chain and so on), the scholars also checked to ensure the character of
each narrator.
4. The scholars developed the science of "Al-Jarh wal Ta'deel", also known
as "Ilm Ar-Rijal" (the knowledge of men). This basically included the
books mentioned earlier which contain a listing of narrators, and
information about them. This science allowed scholars to classify
narrators into classes based on the strength of their memorization and
their Islamic character. Therefore, hadith would be taken only from people
with good character who have good memorization. If someone has good
memorization but sometimes makes mistakes in memorization, the hadith may
be taken but is put into a lower class.
5. Classifying hadith into classes. This includes "motawatir" hadith
(narrated by a large number of people in every generation of the chain of narrators),
then sahih, hasan, da'eef and finally mawdoo' (fabricated). They depended on the
following factors in this classification:
Having a continuous sanad (chain of narrators) with no gaps.
The character of the narrators
The quality of the memorization of the narrators
The matn (wording) of the hadith does not contradict
the Qur'an or other sahih hadith.
The hadith does not have any subtle reasons in the sanad
that makes it weak (called 'illa in Arabic).
Having other hadith with the same meaning to back the hadith up.
6. Exposing liars and fabricators by letting all Muslims know that they are liars and warning
people not to listen to any hadith from them or take their word for
anything.
7. Writing books that include "mawdoo' hadith", or fabricated hadith, and
proving why they are fabricated. These books are written to warn Muslims
from taking such hadith as true.
8. Checking for signs of fabrication in the wording of the hadith. This
can include the style of the wording, as the Prophet was known to be
extremely eloquent in his wording. It also includes checking that the
wording does not contradict the basics of Islam, and that it doesn't
contradict things known for sure by the human mind. It also includes
checking for historical accuracy if the hadith is reporting an action
during a certain time and so on.
10. Conclusion:
In conclusion, after the very quick and brief
discussion in this article, we hope that it will be clear to all Muslims
that the Sunnah was memorized and written during the time of the Prophet
Mohammad, and that it was officially collected very early in Islam. We
also hope that Muslims now have a better idea about some of the efforts
of the scholars of Islam in ensuring the accuracy of the hadith that they
have reported in their books.
Now that we are confident about the Sunnah, the next subject that Muslims
should learn about is the "hojjiyat Assunah", or the Authority of the
Sunnah. In that discussion, we shall talk about the different types of the
Sunnah, and our obligation towards it, and we shall prove that it is
obligatory on every Muslim to follow the Sunnah of Prophet Mohammad
(pbuh). Please see the link below to visit the article on the "Authority
of the Sunnah".
May Allah (swt) guide us all to the right path.